Welcome to the Sex Matters memo, a weekly roundup on sex and gender. This week: 
  • Gay cake battle rejected by European Court
  • Girls' schools group issues single-sex admittance policy
  • Prisoners ditch trans identities upon release
  • Jackie Doyle-Price MP demands that government protects women
  • Stonewall releases accounts
  • Leading child-transition advocate publicly questions WPATH
You're receiving this newsletter because you're a regular donor to Sex Matters. Thank you for your support!
Gay Cake Case
Yesterday the European Court of Human Rights ruled in the "gay cake case" in favour of the UK government. The Supreme Court's ruling in favour of the bakers is therefore upheld. 

Sex Matters welcomes this outcome. The freedom not to be forced to express beliefs you do not share is an important human right. 

This legal battle started in 2014, when Christian-run bakery Ashers refused to make a cake with the slogan "Support Gay Marriage" for gay-rights activist Gareth Lee.

The Supreme Court had ruled in the bakers' favour, saying that the bakery had refused to provide the cake to Mr Lee not because he was a gay man or because he supported gay marriage, but because the message they were being asked to produce conflicted with their profoundly held beliefs. 

While many people initially saw the case as being about sexual orientation versus religious conservatism, it has become clear that it is about tolerance versus compelled speech.

Gareth Lee said: "Everyone has freedom of expression and it must equally apply to lesbian, gay, bisexual and trans people."

Kate Harris, co-founder and director of the LGB Alliance, welcomed the ruling, stating: "This decision is an incredibly important blow for liberty and tolerance. There is a world of difference between denying people a service because of their sexuality and refusing to bake a cake with a political message."
Guidance: girls' schools are for girls

A group of the UK's leading girls' schools, Girls' Day School Trust (GDST), has updated its guidance to ensure that the schools it represents stay single-sex.

GDST has stated that having an admissions policy based on "gender identity rather than the legal sex recorded on a student’s birth certificate would jeopardise the status" of single-sex schools.

While male pupils who identify as girls will be excluded, females who identify as boys will be supported to remain at the school for as long as they wish to do so.

School leaders have complained that at present there is no official guidance from the Equality and Human Rights Commission or the Department for Education, and that as a result, schools are forced to turn to lobby groups for advice.

Ex-cons go ex-trans

Women prisoners in Scotland have reported that male inmates who identify as trans ditch their cross-sex identities on release. Their experiences were published in a paper for the British Journal of Criminology by Dr Matthew Maycock of Dundee University and reported in The Times

One inmate explained that she was put on work duty with a trans-identified prisoner who she says just "wanted to have sex with loads of lassies". 

The research has raised fresh concerns about gender self-identification posing a risk to women’s safety as first minister Nicola Sturgeon prepares to press ahead with gender recognition legislation this year.

A Freedom of Information request revealed that 12 trans-identified prisoners convicted of violence or sexual crimes have been accommodated in Scottish women’s jails within the past 18 months. Only one had transitioned fully; the others had simply identified as women.

MP says sex matters
Jackie Doyle-Price MP has written an excoriating article for The Times in which she urges the government to stand up for sex-based rights.

The Conservative member for Thurrock lambasted the Women and Equalities Select Committee (WESC), of which she is a member, for calling for gender self-identification.

Doyle-Price wrote: "A government that is rightly prioritising combating violence against women and girls cannot ignore the challenges that self-ID poses to women’s safety." She also took aim at Stonewall, stating that the prevalence of gender self-identification policies across statutory bodies was a "consequence of government sub-contracting the equalities agenda" to the lobby group.

She concluded by urging the government to issue "an unambiguous statement from government that the Equalities Act protects single-sex spaces like hospital wards, prisons, refuges and rape crisis centres as well as women-only sporting competitions".
Stonewall accounts: Government funds swamp personal donations

Wednesday saw the release of Stonewall's accounts. They cover an 18-month period, but on an annualised basis they show that individual donations are down from over ÂŁ1million to ÂŁ0.9m. Overall income is down by 7% and the organisation is continuing to make a loss, as it has every year since 2017. 

The figures show that much of Stonewall's funding comes not from individual supporters but from the UK government and multinational corporations. Fee income (which largely comes from the Diversity Champions Scheme) was stable and provides over 40% of the charity's income. 

Stonewall was awarded some hefty UK Government grants: ÂŁ765,061 from the Foreign and Commonwealth Office over the 18 months (this will have included international aid grants under the old Department for International Development). The Welsh Government gave ÂŁ236,529 and the Scottish Government ÂŁ150,000. The Department for Education, which gave a grant of ÂŁ299,612 in 2019, has dropped off the donors list, but the Government Equalities Office has stepped in with ÂŁ50,393.

Ex-WPATH member speaks out

A leading US psychologist, Berkeley-based Erica Anderson, has sounded the alarm about the high numbers of children seeking to transition.

A former president of the US Professional Association for Transgender Health (USPATH), former board member of the influential World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) and transwoman, Anderson built a reputation as a "gender-affirming" pioneer in the field of juvenile transition.

But in a new interview published in Quillette, Anderson slammed USPATH and WPATH for their reluctance to engage openly with the media and answer difficult questions about the implications of administering puberty blockers to children.

"I'm worried that gender minority identities have become a bit trendy," Anderson said. "There’s a new group of adolescents who have pre-existing mental-health problems, and they're looking for solutions, and they're looking for an explanation for who they are."

What to read and watch

Read this powerful article from disabled feminist activist Dr Em on endemic abuse in care homes and why disabled women need female-only carers.

If you haven't yet seen the staggering exchange between substitute Talk Radio presenter James Max and campaigner Kellie-Jay Keen, watch it here.

Read Neale Hanvey MP on Nicola Sturgeon's push to introduce gender self-identification in Scotland.

There was a bumper BBC Woman's Hour this Wednesday, which included interviews with Pragna Patel on the folly of identity politics and Lisa Mackenzie of policy group MBM on the Scottish GRA consultation.

Sex Matters' own Ulrike Bullerby was asked to appear with James Max to follow up on the "full and frank" discussion with Kellie-Jay Keen (listen here). Bullerby then wrote about the conversation for The Critic.

And finally...
From Boy George talking nonsense about the "goddess energy" to yet more attempts to cancel the uncancellable J.K. Rowling, the first week of 2022 has been packed with bonkers statements by transactivists and hilarious put-downs.

Perhaps the finest was a Twitter exchange between GB News presenter Tom Harwood and evolutionary biologist Emma Hilton.






As a tribute to Hilton’s epic response, the inimitable Moley created the "doggit".

Received this newsletter from someone else? 
Become a regular supporter of Sex Matters
Twitter
Facebook
LinkedIn
Website

© Sex Matters, 2022. All rights reserved.
Sex Matters is a not-for-profit company registered by guarantee. Company number: 12974690
Registered office: 63/66 Hatton Garden, Fifth Floor Suite 23, London, EC1N 8LE

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list.